-
Who This Checklist Is For
-
The 7-Step Sourcing Checklist
-
Step 1: Nail the compliance requirements before anyone mentions price
-
Step 2: Match the sensor spec sheet to the actual install site
-
Step 3: Run the OEM and private label numbers side by side, using landed cost
-
Step 4: Lock the lead time in writing, then ask what happens when it slips
-
Step 5: Test samples in the real install environment, not on your desk
-
Step 6: Read the warranty against labor cost, not unit cost
-
Step 7: Add "batch consistency" to your acceptance criteria
-
Step 1: Nail the compliance requirements before anyone mentions price
-
Common Mistakes to Watch For
-
A Note on Brand Specs
Who This Checklist Is For
This is for lighting distributors, electrical contractors, and OEM buyers placing wholesale orders for motion sensor switches, dimmers, LED drivers, and control systems — the kind of orders where a missed spec or a late shipment lands on your invoice, not someone else's.
I've been handling lighting controls purchasing for seven years. Nine significant mistakes along the way, roughly $12,400 in wasted budget. The checklist below is what came out of it.
The 7-Step Sourcing Checklist
Step 1: Nail the compliance requirements before anyone mentions price
This is the one people skip. If you're quoting a job in California — Newport Beach, Irvine, anywhere in that market — the project likely falls under Title 24 energy code, and that code has specific requirements for automatic lighting controls, occupancy sensing, and dimming. Ask early: what sensor type is specified? Is there a mandatory dimming requirement? Is a power pack needed?
In 2021, I quoted 400 motion sensors on a residential job, all hardwired models. Came back rejected — the spec called for low-voltage sensors with power packs. All 400 had to be returned and re-ordered. $1,800 in return shipping and re-purchase costs, plus three weeks lost.
Get the code and spec questions answered before you price anything. Everything else builds on this.
Step 2: Match the sensor spec sheet to the actual install site
Coverage area, field of view, mounting height, detection technology — those numbers on the datasheet are measured under ideal conditions. Your job site is not ideal conditions.
PIR versus ultrasonic sensing behaves differently in an open-plan office than it does in a stairwell. There's a reason the manufacturer publishes both a "maximum coverage" figure and a "recommended coverage" figure. Use the second one.
I keep a highlighter and go through the spec sheet line by line, then ask one question: at this mounting height, with this ceiling type, what's the realistic detection range? If the answer sounds like a guess, get it in writing.
Step 3: Run the OEM and private label numbers side by side, using landed cost
For recessed lighting especially, the OEM vs. private label decision is rarely about unit price. Pull everything into one sheet: tooling fees, packaging, MOQ, lead time, and any penalty for late delivery. Then look at total landed cost, not the quoted unit number.
Here's the counterintuitive part: sometimes the OEM option looks 8% more expensive per unit, but the lower MOQ and tighter lead time make it cheaper on the back end. The reverse is also true — private label can look cheaper until you realize you're holding three months of inventory that isn't converting to cash.
Sample approval is not the same as production consistency. They get tested in different places.
Step 4: Lock the lead time in writing, then ask what happens when it slips
"About four weeks" means nothing. "Ships no later than business day 18 from PO confirmation" means something. If a supplier won't put a date in writing, that tells you something too.
I've been burned twice by verbal lead times. The second time cost a retail project three weeks on a timeline that was already tight going into February.
In March 2024, I paid an 11% rush premium on an order that had a hard event deadline. The alternative was cheaper by about 6% but only offered an "estimated" ship window. I paid the premium, got the confirmation, and slept fine. The extra cost bought the certainty, not the speed.
Step 5: Test samples in the real install environment, not on your desk
A sensor works on a desk. Does it work in an open-plan office with an HVAC vent blowing twelve feet away? Does it work when the thermostat nearby spikes the ambient temperature in the afternoon?
We approved 580 motion sensors for a commercial office fit-out in 2023 based on bench testing. After install, 42 came back out because of detection delay issues. Each pull-and-replace cost about $47 in labor — roughly $1,970 gone, and that's before shipping.
Sample testing needs to include: airflow from vents, ambient temperature swings, obstacles in the coverage path, and the distance from sensor to farthest trigger point. None of those show up in a conference room demo.
Step 6: Read the warranty against labor cost, not unit cost
A failed sensor costs a few dollars to replace. It costs 0.3 hours of labor to diagnose, remove, and re-install. Warranty terms are only meaningful when you compare them against the labor number, not the product number.
Break it into three parts before you sign: how long is coverage, is it replacement or refund, and who pays return freight. On a typical control component order, the unit price difference between suppliers is small. The real money is in what happens after failure.
Step 7: Add "batch consistency" to your acceptance criteria
This one is last because it's the one most people skip. First samples and first production run are usually fine. The problems show up in lots three, five, and eight. Slight color temperature drift. Driver noise that wasn't there in the sample. Dimming curve that doesn't feel the same.
Start pulling consistency samples from lot two onward. Check color temperature, inrush current, dimming curve, and sensor response delay. You don't need to test every lot — first article, middle, and final piece from each shipment is enough. If one fails, hold the lot.
Common Mistakes to Watch For
The biggest one: locking in price before locking in specs. Once price is fixed, every adjustment afterward gets pulled out of the product somewhere else — usually in a spot the customer won't see until after install.
The second one: treating a showroom or conference room demo as proof of field performance. Showrooms are cleaner than any real job site. Airflow, temperature, and traffic patterns don't exist in a lab.
The third one: reading price differences as quality signals. Sometimes a lower quote reflects real efficiency. Sometimes it reflects cash flow pressure, or a different lot of components. Understand the reason before you decide which one to take.
A Note on Brand Specs
When a project spec calls for a specific brand of occupancy sensor or control system — Lutron, for instance — confirm what the specifier actually means. Sometimes it's a brand requirement. Sometimes it's a placeholder for "any code-compliant sensor with these specs." That distinction drives your sourcing options more than any price negotiation will.
(Note to self: update the batch consistency sampling frequency from quarterly to monthly. We got lucky last quarter.)

